Academic Voices

aims to build the ACW community by sharing the experiences of academic writers.

Subscribe to
Academic Voices
Academic Coaching & Writing

Writing a Literature Review

As an academic writer, you are expected to provide an analytical overview of the significant literature published on your topic. If your audience knows less than you do on the topic, your purpose is instructional. If the audience knows more than you do, your purpose is to demonstrate familiarity, expertise, and intelligence with the topic. In your review of literature you are expected to do the following:

  • Place one's original work in the context of existing literature.
  • Interpret the major issues surrounding your topic.
  • Describe the relationship of each work to the others under consideration.
  • Identify new ways to interpret, and shed light on any gaps in previous research.
  • Resolve conflicts among seemingly contradictory previous studies.
  • Determine which literature makes a significant contribution to the understanding of your topic.
  • Point the way to further research on your topic.

Content of the Literature Review

The Literature Review must be well structured, and your ideas must flow logically from one point to the next. Ensure sources and references are current and relevant, cited appropriately according to your discipline. Present terminology and viewpoints on the topic in an unbiased and comprehensive manner.

Include the following content in your Literature Review:

  • Provide an overview of the subject, issue, or theory under consideration.
  • Divide outside works into categories and concepts (in support or against a particular position).
  • Connect the works to what has come before your work and ideas.
  • Provide conclusions about those works that make the greatest contribution to the understanding and development of your subject.

Consider the following when assessing whether to include each work in your review of literature:

  • Qualifications: What are the author's credentials to make the judgments he or she has made?
  • Neutrality: Is the author's perspective even-handed or biased?
  • Credibility: Which of the author's theses are convincing and why?
  • Worth: Do the author's conclusions add to the value of your own?

Your transitions between ideas analyze, synthesize, and assess these outside perspectives, and do not simply summarize or translate them.

Your attitude towards works that you present, either in support or against your topic, through the use of reporting verbs which allow the writer to convey clearly whether the claims in the outside work are to be taken as accepted or not. Use reporting verbs to indicate

  • Positive assessment (advocate, argue, hold, see);
  • Neutral assessment (address, cite, comment, look at);
  • Tentative assessment (allude to, believe, hypothesize, suggest); or
  • Critical assessment (attack, condemn, object, refute).

The way you present the evidence or material in the Literature Review needs to show that you are:

  • Selecting and quoting only the most relevant material for your subject and argument.
  • Making sense of the quotation within the context of your argument.
  • Introducing and integrating only relevant quotations into your literature review.
  • Focusing on the language of quotations in the interpretations.

Through citations,  situate your research in a larger narrative. The conscientious use of citations reflects your decisions to give greater emphasis to either the reported author or the reported message.

  • Integral citations are those where the name of the cited author occurs in the citing sentence.
  • Non-integral citations make reference to the author in parenthesis or through end or footnotes.

Your ideas should be at the center of your writing, but your work has to be embedded in what has come before to demonstrate its relevance and importance to the subject.  The Literature Review connects your ideas to the ideas in your field.

Copyright © 2019 Academic Coaching and Writing LLC. All rights reserved. Dissertation Doctor is a registered trademark of Academic Coaching and Writing LLC.
Dissertation Coach - Academic Writing Coach - Tenure Coach

0 0 0